The
Hunchback of Notre Dame has been
one of my favorite movies since I was a child—Yes… and I cried like everybody
else when I watched it for the very first time, I must confess. For those who
may not know it, this is an animated musical drama film produced by Walt Disney
Feature Animation and it was released in 1996.
Believe it or not, I was reading the play Twelfth Night when this movie, suddenly,
came up to my mind and without noticing, my neurons started making some connections
by relating one topic presented in the play to another exposed in the movie.
For that reason, I decided to look for some information on the Internet—the
greatest savior of work groups nowadays—in order to find out if my ideas were
going to make sense at some point.
So,
here we go. First of all, The Hunchback of Notre Dame is a French Gothic novel
by Victor Hugo and it was published in 1831. Nevertheless, the story takes
place in Paris in 1482—Ok, first thing that makes me think that I am not
entirely lost, because Twelfth Night was written around 1601.
The
word that really made me think of this movie was “carnival”. At the very
beginning of this movie, a carnival, The Carnival of Fools, is exposed, and
like it is stated in one part of the song performed by Clopin, the mischievous leader of the
gypsies, "everything in this carnival turns upside down." From this point, we can see all the
people of the city, from the lower to the upper classes, having fun together by
drinking, singing, and disguising themselves; actually, there is a competition
of masks portrayed like the main event of this festivity. In connection with
the play, by the time that Twelfth Night was written, people used to celebrate
this carnival—Twelfth Night—where everything was ruled by madness and
craziness; indeed, during this festivity, men used to disguise like women and
vice versa—Am I making myself clear?
There
is another point that I was able to analyze with the help of my friends, and I
would like to share it with you as well. The character of Feste, the trixiter,
is pretty similar to Clopin, this mischievous gypsy that narrates the story of
the hunchback since the beginning of the movie and who seems to be an
omniscient narrator; for some reason, he knows everything concerning the
character’s lives. Like Feste, who was Olivia’s servant, he was wise (trixters
were supposed to be smart, but portrayed the role of clowns in society) free,
and even though he interacted with all the characters, he didn’t belong to
their realities, for he knew everything about them—Does it make any sense?
What do you think? I’m looking forward to reading your
comments in order to exchange more ideas!
Sergio Reyes
Sergio Reyes
I think you made your point very clear. Even though I saw this movie years ago, I remember some of the moments that you mention; however, it reminds me Bakhtin’s text about Rabelais and His World. The introduction of the text, as you must know, analyses the topic of carnival and emphasizes that citizens live in it, that there are not any hierarchical orders or privileges among the participants, it is the time in which people are free to feel, to do and even to behave differently from what they actually are during their daily routines. Maybe your analysis is also connected with what I think and my comment is a complement to it.
ResponderEliminarAnyway, it is necessary to have reality in order to enjoy those carnivalesque moments in our lives.
Vera.
I think you are right, I can clearly see your point here. But also I would like to add that this movie showes the grotesque too. I still remember when I was little that I asked my mom why they all look crazy and mad in the scene of the carnival, she just answered: "that's an adult's party". The funny part is that we show to our kids what our games, as society, do in order to have fun and I guess it is impossible to avoid reactions like that. Certainly, Disney showed in this movie more than a simple tale, even the sound track is deeper and easily to be analyzed. As the Esmeralda's song "God helps the outcasts", which depicted the situations of the ones who were recognized as pagans. I'm leaving the link of the song here as a reminder,
ResponderEliminarhttp://www.youtube.com/watch?v=MEEpavnk7Uw
Great idea!